It would seem so if I'm reading the macrolet define-closer-common-lisp-package correctly: https://github.com/pcostanza/closer-mop/blob/master/closer-mop-packages.lisp Since the example is supposed to be expository rather than a a professional code snippet I see no problem with your suggestion. An expert would factor that in, I would think, and people like me wouldn't know the difference. Russell On 1/10/25 1:18 PM, Robert Goldman wrote:
There's a problem with this patch that highlights a problem with the example.
The problem is that the package |:closer-common-lisp| is a new package that exports all the external symbols in |:closer-mop| (a portability layer for the meta object protocol) /and/ all the external symbols of |:common-lisp|. So adding |:cl| to the |:use| list in this example does nothing.
I /think/ a better fix for this example would be to replace | (:use :closer-common-lisp)| with |(:use :cl :closer-mop)| everywhere.
On 10 Jan 2025, at 11:49, Russell L. Carter wrote:
Hi Robert, I decided against modifying the UIOP doc because although the existing wording is quite concise it is also correct, AFAICT. Any edits I could conceive would alter the style and as a maker of many words myself I am loathe to do that.
I'm also open to any style nitpicks in this tiny patch. I'm not interested in being different from existing code conventions, etc.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
doc/asdf.texinfo | 4 ++-- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-)
diff --git a/doc/asdf.texinfo b/doc/asdf.texinfo index cc3aa287..5da42b32 100644 --- a/doc/asdf.texinfo +++ b/doc/asdf.texinfo @@ -2131,7 +2131,7 @@ ASDF will compute dependencies from the
@example (uiop:define-package :my-lib/interface/order
* (:use :closer-common-lisp
* (:use :cl :closer-common-lisp :my-lib/interface/definition :my-lib/interface/base) (:mix :fare-utils :uiop :alexandria)
@@ -2152,7 +2152,7 @@ context. For example: @example (uiop:define-package :my-lib/interface/all (:nicknames :my-lib-interface)
* (:use :closer-common-lisp)
* (:use :cl :closer-common-lisp) (:mix :fare-utils :uiop :alexandria) (:use-reexport :my-lib/interface/definition
-- 2.45.2
On 1/9/25 5:38 PM, Robert Goldman wrote:
Thank you! A patch will be very welcome.
On 9 Jan 2025, at 16:01, Russell L. Carter wrote:
|I will do this tomorrow. Russell On 1/9/25 4:56 PM, Faré wrote: On Thu, Jan 9, 2025, 10:16 Russell L. Carter <rcarter@pinyon.org <mailto:rcarter@pinyon.org> mailto:rcarter@pinyon.org <mailto:rcarter@pinyon.org>> wrote: |Finally I'll note that the only examples I've seen, and I actually did suck down the repo for lisp-interface-library, *do not show :use :cl*. For instance have a look at the code snippets from the ASDF.pdf manual on page 26. There are two there, and neither has a use :cl or :common-lisp or whatever. To fix this is trivial. Add in a :use :cl in those code snippets, and perhaps add "be sure to add :use :cl if you :use any other systems" in the docs for uiop:define-package. | Are you frustrated enough to locate and fix all the misleading documentation? I admit I'm fully responsible for getting it wrong, but I have ceased being active in Common Lisp or as an ASDF developer long ago. (These days: Gerbil Scheme, and... some Haskell recently.) The current maintainers and future documentation readers will thank you. git grep -i define-package should help you. Regards, -#f |