I tried to specify a build-time dependency for ASDF system, and failed.
The defsystem option
:depends-on systems
makes “systems” both build-time and runtime dependencies of a system being defined. I'm interested in specifying a dependency that is required at build time only.
I attempted
(defsystem "test-toplevel-in-order-deps" :in-order-to ((compile-op (load-op "some-macros"))) :components ((:file "a") (:file "b")))
but this way, some-macros is loaded too late:
(let ((system (find-system "test-toplevel-in-order-deps"))) (plan-actions (make-plan 'sequential-plan 'compile-op system))) ;; =>
((#<PREPARE-OP > . #<SYSTEM "test-toplevel-in-order-deps">) (#<PREPARE-OP > . #<CL-SOURCE-FILE "test-toplevel-in-order-deps" "a">) (#<COMPILE-OP > . #<CL-SOURCE-FILE "test-toplevel-in-order-deps" "a">) (#<PREPARE-OP > . #<CL-SOURCE-FILE "test-toplevel-in-order-deps" "b">) (#<COMPILE-OP > . #<CL-SOURCE-FILE "test-toplevel-in-order-deps" "b">) (#<PREPARE-OP > . #<SYSTEM "some-macros">) ... (#<LOAD-OP > . #<SYSTEM "some-macros">) (#<COMPILE-OP > . #<SYSTEM "test-toplevel-in-order-deps">))
I'm not requesting a feature but still, it's unfortunate that a seemingly basic task of specifying build-time dependency is unachievable in ASDF.
My hypothesis is, if (compile-op . parent) depends on “actions”, then compiling children of parent should depend on “actions” as well, and similarly for all instances of downward-operation. I'm not sure what's the best way to implement this but I wonder if you find this reasonable in the first place.