If you let me know what Jenkins happens to be then I may be able to give a look at the problem. I have been planning an update to the latest ASDF for my upcoming (RSN) release of MKCL 1.1.11, so I may as well squeeze that question in.
Regards,
JCB
On Mon, Feb 19, 2018 at 6:56 PM, Robert Goldman rpgoldman@sift.info wrote:
The failure isn't replicable to me, which bothers me some. I suspect it means that it's having side-effects in the file system that aren't entirely cleaned up. I'm eyeballing the test and it *does* affect the filesystem, and it does not remove the files (really symlinks) it creates. So ... potentially there could be insufficiently controlled side-effects that gave me a transient failure? I don't know. I suppose it's also possible that it does something with the filesystem that Jenkins isn't allowed to do, and that's why I got the Jenkins-only failure. But that explanation doesn't explain why I get failure only with Jenkins *and* MKCL.
On 19 Feb 2018, at 16:43, Faré wrote:
test-multiple works for me with asdf 3.3.1.4, mkcl 1.1.10.19-2dbfa99 on Linux 4.14 x64.
This is all long gone from my mental cache. The test could be better commented, but I suppose the purpose can be extracted by looking at its history then looking at related commits, bugs, bug fix commits, mailing-list messages, etc. A starting point: git log --stat test/test-multiple.*
Apparently, it tests support for what is now considered misnamed secondary systems, but was once a kind-of-supported feature, seen in the wild, with nasty consequences sometimes (e.g. infinite loop with quicklisp until relevant fix).
A variable not being rebound is a test that a file hasn't been reloaded.
I'd rather not add comments, but I'll review them gladly.
—♯ƒ • François-René ÐVB Rideau •Reflection&Cybernethics• http://fare.tunes.org Everyone hates a martyr. It's no wonder martyrs were burnt at a stake. — E.W. Howe, "Country Town Sayings", p.7
On Mon, Feb 19, 2018 at 5:21 PM, Robert Goldman rpgoldman@sift.info wrote:
Faré ---
Would you please add some comments to test-multiple? I got a failure on that with MKCL under jenkins on linux, but cannot replicate that failure running it myself.
There's no comment saying what this is supposed to test, other than the name, which suggests that it's about testing where there are ... multiple systems defined (incorrectly) in one .asd file? the same systems defined in multiple .asd files?
The test checks to make sure (I believe) that a variable is not rebound when we ask to reload a system, but not how this pertains to correct ASDF function.
thanks! r