On Mon, Jun 16, 2014 at 9:20 PM, Faré fahree@gmail.com wrote:
Interestingly, uiop/common-lisp.lisp sets clos::*redefine-class-in-place* in uiop/common-lisp — is the problem due to your compiling asdf/defsystem separately, and bind r-c-i-p in LOAD, so that this setting doesn't apply to asdf/defsystem?
I thought this was one possible problem but obviously this is not the one you hit upon. (And I believe it still is a loophole worth closing).
At first, your solution looked like it wasn't working. Then, I tried to reproduce, and then it worked against ASDF 3.1.2. But still not against the syntax-control branch. I'm confused.
It turns out that I have never taken time to do a complete and detailed inspection of each and every location in the MKCL's code where object up-to-date-ness is required, until now that is. And what you hit upon, trying to do your ASDF upgrade, revealed a good number of gaping holes inside MKCL in that area. So now I hope I have plugged all of them properly without missing one.
The whole fix is in MKCL's git repo master head. I tried it on my copy of ASDF syntax-control branch head and it worked OK. Could you please confirm that it also works for you?
This will be part of MKCL 1.1.9 that I will push out the door as a released version in a few days from now.
Thank you for your help solving this MKCL's issue.
Cher JCB,
The whole fix is in MKCL's git repo master head. I tried it on my copy of ASDF syntax-control branch head and it worked OK. Could you please confirm that it also works for you?
I ran cl -l mkcl -ip :ok which worked with both asdf 3.1.2 and the syntax-control branch, which is progress as compared to my attempts yesterday or so.
The upgrade test also worked (on the syntax-control branch). Congratulations!
This will be part of MKCL 1.1.9 that I will push out the door as a released version in a few days from now.
Thank you for your help solving this MKCL's issue.
Can you upgrade your ASDF from 3.0.3.0.2 to 3.1.2? Does 3.1.2 require a patch? If it does, then let's get it pushed upstream into e.g. 3.1.2.5.
NB: please send a diff; I can review it, but Robert should commit and push it — I'm out of this business (except for the branches I wrote and would like to see merged — Robert, any news about them?)
PS: minor issue, but when I (quit), I get this annoying message:
(quit)
;; MKCL shutdown: Thread refused to be interrupted: Sleeping thread: #<thread "Imported thread pool filler daemon" active detached (27380) 0x7f1aa19d0700 0000000003286000>, in file threads.d at line 1076. ;; MKCL shutdown: Killing thread #<thread "Imported thread pool filler daemon" active detached (27380) 0x7f1aa19d0700 0000000003286000>.
—♯ƒ • François-René ÐVB Rideau •Reflection&Cybernethics• http://fare.tunes.org "Ask not what the government can do for you. Ask what the government is doing to you." — David Friedman, "The Machinery of Freedom", p. 21
On my linux box, I confirm that mkcl now passes the asdf upgrade tests on both master and syntax-case branches.
-
Faré -
Jean-Claude Beaudoin -
Robert Goldman