The only blocker I have right now is testing on Windows. The tests pass for me on all the implementations I have on both Linux and Mac OS X.

As far as implementations, I don't have clasp, mkcl, Genera, Corman, or ECL, and my clisp is woefully old. But other than that I have pretty good coverage.

I'm hoping we can get some Windows tests from Dave Cooper, and if those come through clean, we can release 3.1.5.

Running on Linux x64 with these implementations: ccl clisp sbcl ecl ecl_bytecodes cmucl allegro lispworks mkcl abcl allegromodern

It passes all tests, though test-program.script is flaky on mkcl due to mkcl sometimes warning about killing a thread on exit. (JCB: How do I disable this warning?)

Anton, can you run cl-test-grid with the latest ASDF 3.1.4.13 from master?

—♯ƒ • François-René ÐVB Rideau •Reflection&Cybernethics• http://fare.tunes.org Faré's Second Law of Dissent: I am Right, whence it follows that all who disagree with me are either (1) evil, (2) stupid or (3) crazy. (The alternatives are not mutually exclusive.) This universal law is valid for all values of "me", including "you".

On 6/8/15 Jun 8 -6:28 PM, Faré wrote:

...

Running on Linux x64 with these implementations: ccl clisp sbcl ecl ecl_bytecodes cmucl allegro lispworks mkcl abcl allegromodern

It passes all tests [...]

As for upgrade tests, I have the following failures:

• clisp won't upgrade from 3.0.1 anymore, but that's OK because it

comes with 3.0.2.26. Actually, trying again, it passes. Dunno why it failed at first.

• cmucl won't upgrade at all; this is a known bug with its CLOS

implementation since the early ASDF 3 days. Disabling upgrade.

Sounds good. What's the bug, BTW? Is it something we can FMAKUNBOUND our way around, or is it just hopeless?

Thanks for rechecking this.

I just finished my Linux checks and they all passed. I will re-run, however, now that you modified the tests one more time. I'll also run the upgrade tests overnight.

With luck, Dave's Windows tests will come back passing, and we can release tomorrow.

cheers, r

With luck, Dave's Windows tests will come back passing, and we can release tomorrow.

Not quite. The next failure looks like it's specific to cygwin, though. At least in Allegro and CCL, when launched from a cygwin bash shell, the "PWD" environment is "/cygdrive/f/..." but this is not recognized by the Lisp -- e.g.

(probe-file (uiop:getenv "PWD")) --> NIL

Should this be considered a bug with the environment, because a Unix-style PWD is being passed into a program which is not guaranteed to understand Unix-style pathnames?

; Loading F:\cl\tests\asdf\asdf-windows\test\script-support.lisp

; Fast loading F:\cl\tests\asdf\asdf-windows\build\fasls\alisp\asdf.fasl

Configuring ASDF

Enabling debugging

Being a bit verbose

Comparing directories

ASDF-TEST:*TEST-DIRECTORY* and

(:PATHNAME-DIRECTORY-PATHNAME (NTH-VALUE 2 (:LOCATE-SYSTEM :TEST-ASDF))) both evaluate to same path:

#P"F:\cl\tests\asdf\asdf-windows\test\"

Frob packages

Running test-encodings.script with acl-9.0-win-x86

; Loading F:\cl\tests\asdf\asdf-windows\test\test-encodings.script

Test TEST-ENCODING-EXPLICIT-U8: should be UTF-8

; Registering #<SYSTEM "test-encoding-explicit-u8">

; Loading F:\cl\tests\asdf\asdf-windows\test\lambda.lisp

TEST ABORTED: illegal namestring: "/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/:/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/uiop/:/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/ext//:" [6]

Evaluation stack:

->(TPL::ZOOM-COMMAND :FROM-READ-EVAL-PRINT-LOOP NIL :COUNT 69 :ALL T)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION "applyn" . #1=(:UNKNOWN-ARGS))

(TPL:DO-COMMAND

"zoom"

:FROM-READ-EVAL-PRINT-LOOP

NIL

:COUNT

69

:ALL

T)

(ASDF/IMAGE:RAW-PRINT-BACKTRACE

:STREAM

#2=#<EXCL:TERMINAL-SIMPLE-STREAM

[initial terminal io] fd 0/1

@

#x200fadea>

:COUNT

69

:CONDITION

#3=#<PARSE-ERROR @ #x205d490a>)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION #4="lisp_apply" . #1#)

((:INTERNAL ASDF/IMAGE:PRINT-BACKTRACE 0))

(ASDF/STREAM:CALL-WITH-SAFE-IO-SYNTAX

#<Closure (:INTERNAL ASDF/IMAGE:PRINT-BACKTRACE 0) @ #x205d491a>)

(ASDF/IMAGE:PRINT-BACKTRACE :STREAM #2# :COUNT 69 :CONDITION #3#)

(ASDF/IMAGE:PRINT-CONDITION-BACKTRACE #3# :STREAM #2# :COUNT 69)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION #4# . #1#)

[... EXCL::EVAL-AS-PROGN ]

(BLOCK

ASDF-TEST:ACALL

(APPLY

(APPLY

'ASDF-TEST:ASYM

(IF

(CONSP ASDF-TEST::NAME)

ASDF-TEST::NAME

(LIST ASDF-TEST::NAME)))

ASDF-TEST::ARGS))

[... EXCL::%EVAL ]

(ASDF-TEST:ACALL

:PRINT-CONDITION-BACKTRACE

#3#

:COUNT

69

:STREAM

#2#)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION

#8="_comp_to_interp"

:PRINT-CONDITION-BACKTRACE

#3#

:COUNT

69

:STREAM

#2#)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION #4# . #1#)

[... EXCL::EVAL-AS-PROGN ]

(LET*

. #6=(((#5=#:G245

(CONS

(LOAD-TIME-VALUE EXCL::.IGNORE-ERRORS-1.)

(EXCL::FAST EXCL::*HANDLER-CLUSTERS*)))

(EXCL::*HANDLER-CLUSTERS* #5#))

(DECLARE (DYNAMIC-EXTENT #5# EXCL::*HANDLER-CLUSTERS*))

(PROGN

. #7=((ASDF-TEST:ACALL

:PRINT-CONDITION-BACKTRACE

ASDF-TEST::C

:COUNT

69

:STREAM

*ERROR-OUTPUT*)))))

[... EXCL::EVAL-AS-PROGN ]

(CATCH 'EXCL::IGNORE-ERRORS-1 (LET* . #6#))

[... EXCL::%EVAL ]

(EXCL::EVAL-AS-PROGN

((IGNORE-ERRORS . #7#) (ASDF-TEST:LEAVE-TEST "Script failed" 1)))

[... EXCL::%EVAL ]

((:INTERNAL ASDF-TEST::CALL-WITH-TEST) #3#)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION #8# #3#)

(SIGNAL #3#)

(ERROR

PARSE-ERROR

:FORMAT-CONTROL

#9="illegal namestring: ~s [~d]"

:FORMAT-ARGUMENTS

#10=("/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/:/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/uiop/:/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/ext//:"

6))

(EXCL::.PARSE-ERROR #9# . #10#)

((FLET EXCL::PARSE-DOS-NAMESTRING EXCL::FAILURE) 6)

(EXCL::PARSE-DOS-NAMESTRINGu

#11="/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/:/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/uiop/:/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/ext//:"

NIL

#P""

0

NIL

NIL)

(PARSE-NAMESTRING #11#)

(PATHNAME #11#)

(ASDF/PATHNAME:ABSOLUTE-PATHNAME-P #11#)

((FLET

ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PARSE-SOURCE-REGISTRY-STRING

ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY::CHECK)

#11#)

(ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PARSE-SOURCE-REGISTRY-STRING

#12="/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/:/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/uiop/:/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/ext//:")

((METHOD ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY #17=(STRING))

#12#

:INHERIT

#13=(ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:USER-SOURCE-REGISTRY

ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:USER-SOURCE-REGISTRY-DIRECTORY

ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:DEFAULT-USER-SOURCE-REGISTRY

ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:SYSTEM-SOURCE-REGISTRY

ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:SYSTEM-SOURCE-REGISTRY-DIRECTORY

ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:DEFAULT-SYSTEM-SOURCE-REGISTRY)

:REGISTER

#14=#<Closure (:INTERNAL

ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:FLATTEN-SOURCE-REGISTRY

0)

@

#x205d554a>)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION #4# . #1#)

((:INTERNAL (:EFFECTIVE-METHOD 1 T T NIL NIL) 0)

#12#

:INHERIT

#13#

:REGISTER

#14#)

[... ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY ]

((METHOD ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY #23=(SYMBOL))

ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:ENVIRONMENT-SOURCE-REGISTRY

:INHERIT

#13#

:REGISTER

#14#)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION #4# . #1#)

((:INTERNAL (:EFFECTIVE-METHOD 1 T T NIL NIL) 0)

ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:ENVIRONMENT-SOURCE-REGISTRY

:REGISTER

#14#

:INHERIT

#13#)

[... ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY ]

(ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY::INHERIT-SOURCE-REGISTRY

#15=(ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:ENVIRONMENT-SOURCE-REGISTRY . #13#)

:REGISTER

#14#)

(ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY::PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY-DIRECTIVE

:INHERIT-CONFIGURATION

:INHERIT

#15#

:REGISTER

#14#)

((METHOD ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY #21=(CONS))

#16=(:SOURCE-REGISTRY :INHERIT-CONFIGURATION)

:INHERIT

#15#

:REGISTER

#14#)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION #4# . #1#)

((:INTERNAL (:EFFECTIVE-METHOD 1 T T NIL NIL) 0)

#16#

:INHERIT

#15#

:REGISTER

#14#)

[... ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY ]

((METHOD ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY #17#)

#18=""

:INHERIT

#15#

:REGISTER

#14#)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION #4# . #1#)

((:INTERNAL (:EFFECTIVE-METHOD 1 T T NIL NIL) 0)

#18#

:REGISTER

#14#

:INHERIT

#15#)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION #4# . #1#)

(EXCL::CACHING-MISS

#24=#<STANDARD-GENERIC-FUNCTION

ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY>

#19=(#18# :REGISTER #14# :INHERIT #15#)

#(0

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

#25=#(32787053 T NIL NIL #<BUILT-IN-CLASS CONS> 0 NIL)

#26=#<Closure (:INTERNAL (:EFFECTIVE-METHOD 1 T T NIL NIL) 0)

@

#x204bf17a>

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

#(32124820 T NIL NIL #<BUILT-IN-CLASS SYMBOL> 0 NIL)

#<Closure (:INTERNAL (:EFFECTIVE-METHOD 1 T T NIL NIL) 0)

@

#x205d5712>

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL))

((:INTERNAL EXCL::UPDATE-TO-CACHING-DFUN 0) . #19#)

[... ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY ]

(ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY::INHERIT-SOURCE-REGISTRY

#20=(#18# . #15#)

:REGISTER

#14#)

(ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY::PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY-DIRECTIVE

:INHERIT-CONFIGURATION

:INHERIT

#20#

:REGISTER

#14#)

((METHOD ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY #21#)

#22=(:SOURCE-REGISTRY :INHERIT-CONFIGURATION)

:INHERIT

#20#

:REGISTER

#14#)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION #4# . #1#)

((:INTERNAL (:EFFECTIVE-METHOD 1 T T NIL NIL) 0)

#22#

:INHERIT

#20#

:REGISTER

#14#)

[... ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY ]

((METHOD ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY #23#)

ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:WRAPPING-SOURCE-REGISTRY

:INHERIT

#20#

:REGISTER

#14#)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION #4# . #1#)

((:INTERNAL (:EFFECTIVE-METHOD 1 T T NIL NIL) 0)

ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:WRAPPING-SOURCE-REGISTRY

:REGISTER

#14#

:INHERIT

#20#)

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION #4# . #1#)

(EXCL::CACHING-MISS

#24#

#27=(ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:WRAPPING-SOURCE-REGISTRY

:REGISTER

#14#

:INHERIT

#20#)

#(0

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

#25#

#26#

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL))

((:INTERNAL EXCL::UPDATE-TO-CACHING-DFUN 0) . #27#)

[... ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:PROCESS-SOURCE-REGISTRY ]

(ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY::INHERIT-SOURCE-REGISTRY

(ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:WRAPPING-SOURCE-REGISTRY . #20#)

:REGISTER

#14#)

(ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:FLATTEN-SOURCE-REGISTRY #18#)

(ASDF/SOURCE-REGISTRY:COMPUTE-SOURCE-REGISTRY #18#)

(ASDF/FIND-SYSTEM:INITIALIZE-SOURCE-REGISTRY #18#)

[... EXCL::%EVAL ]

(EVAL

(UNLESS

(ASDF/SYSTEM:FIND-SYSTEM :ASDF-ENCODINGS NIL)

(ASDF/FIND-SYSTEM:INITIALIZE-SOURCE-REGISTRY #18#)))

(EXCL::SLOLOAD

#28=#<EXCL:FILE-SIMPLE-STREAM

#29=#P"F:\cl\tests\asdf\asdf-windows\test\test-encodings.script" for input pos 2870

@

#x204d5a32>)

(EXCL::LOAD-FROM-STREAM-OR-BUNDLE #28# #29# NIL T 2 NIL NIL)

(EXCL::LOAD-2

#30="test-encodings.script"

T

#31=(#P""

#P(:TYPE "fasl")

#P(:TYPE "cl")

#P(:TYPE "lisp")

#P(:TYPE "lsp"))

:ERROR

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

:DEFAULT

NIL

NIL)

(EXCL::LOAD-1

#30#

T

#31#

:ERROR

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

:DEFAULT

NIL

NIL)

(LOAD #30#)

[... EXCL::EVAL-AS-PROGN ]

(LET

((ASDF-TEST::NAME (STRING ASDF-TEST::FILE)))

(FORMAT

T

"Running ~A with ~A~%"

ASDF-TEST::NAME

(ASDF-TEST:ACALL :IMPLEMENTATION-IDENTIFIER))

(LOAD ASDF-TEST::NAME))

[... EXCL::%EVAL ]

((:INTERNAL ASDF-TEST:RUN-TEST-SCRIPT))

(SYS::..RUNTIME-OPERATION #8#)

... more older frames ...

Above backtrace due to this condition:

illegal namestring: "/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/:/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/uiop/:/cygdrive/f/cl/tests/asdf/asdf-windows/ext//:" [6]

Script failed

<The Lisp process exited with status 1 (0x1)>

Considering that this is asdf choking on the CL_SOURCE_REGISTRY defined by the Makefile, which itself can be overridden using ASDF_DEVEL_SOURCE_REGISTRY, can you export the latter environment variable using Windows-style paths and ; as separator? Note that to avoid having to count backslashes in presence of an indeterminate number of levels of quoting, you may want to keep forward slashes.

—♯ƒ • François-René ÐVB Rideau •Reflection&Cybernethics• http://fare.tunes.org Nothing is so permanent as a temporary government program. - Milton Friedman

On Tue, Jun 9, 2015 at 12:29 PM, Robert Goldman rpgoldman@sift.net wrote:

On 6/9/15 Jun 9 -11:19 AM, Dave Cooper wrote:

...

With luck, Dave's Windows tests will come back passing, and we can
release tomorrow.

Not quite. The next failure looks like it's specific to cygwin, though. At least in Allegro and CCL, when launched from a cygwin bash shell, the "PWD" environment is "/cygdrive/f/..." but this is not recognized by the Lisp -- e.g.

cygwin is a mess. It's an operating system, but no it's not an operating system.

My best guess is that the Lisps would have to be told that they are running under cygwin in some sense, so that they would know to use the cygwin equivalents to the standard posix commands, instead of using the real operating system, which is Windows.

The only thing I can think of would be if we could find something in the environment that would indicate that we're in cygwin context. I don't know what that would be. Does cygwin set some standard environment variable?

Even then, I'm not sure how the lisp implementation could figure out how to find the right cygwin programs....