Carl Shapiro pushed to branch master at cmucl / cmucl

Commits: a8ced15b by Carl Shapiro at 2023-08-14T04:45:23+00:00 Address #196: Fix issues with mapping and nconc accumulation

- - - - - 310e41eb by Carl Shapiro at 2023-08-14T04:45:41+00:00 Merge branch 'mapcan' into 'master'

Address #196: Fix issues with mapping and nconc accumulation

See merge request cmucl/cmucl!162 - - - - -

3 changed files:

- src/code/list.lisp - src/compiler/seqtran.lisp - + tests/list.lisp

Changes:

===================================== src/code/list.lisp ===================================== @@ -1050,7 +1050,10 @@ (setf (car l) (cdar l))) (setq res (apply function (nreverse args))) (case accumulate - (:nconc (setq temp (last (nconc temp res)))) + (:nconc (when res + (let ((next-temp (last res))) + (rplacd temp res) + (setq temp next-temp)))) (:list (rplacd temp (list res)) (setq temp (cdr temp)))))))

===================================== src/compiler/seqtran.lisp ===================================== @@ -36,12 +36,18 @@ (ecase accumulate (:nconc (let ((temp (gensym)) - (map-result (gensym))) + (map-result (gensym)) + (res (gensym)) + (next-temp (gensym))) `(let ((,map-result (list nil))) (declare (dynamic-extent ,map-result)) (do-anonymous ((,temp ,map-result) . ,(do-clauses)) (,endtest (cdr ,map-result)) - (setq ,temp (last (nconc ,temp ,call))))))) + (let ((,res ,call)) + (when ,res + (let ((,next-temp (last ,res))) + (rplacd ,temp ,res) + (setq ,temp ,next-temp)))))))) (:list (let ((temp (gensym)) (map-result (gensym)))

===================================== tests/list.lisp ===================================== @@ -0,0 +1,193 @@ +(defpackage "LIST-TESTS" + (:use "COMMON-LISP" + "LISP-UNIT")) + +(in-package "LIST-TESTS") + +(define-test mapcan-empty-list-returns-nil + (locally (declare (notinline mapcan)) + (assert-equal '() (mapcan #'identity '()))) + (locally (declare (inline mapcan)) + (assert-equal '() (mapcan #'identity '())))) + +(define-test mapcon-empty-list-returns-nil + (locally (declare (notinline mapcon)) + (assert-equal '() (mapcon #'identity '()))) + (locally (declare (inline mapcon)) + (assert-equal '() (mapcon #'identity '())))) + +(define-test mapcan-accumulate-non-nil-signals-type-error + (locally (declare (notinline mapcan)) + (assert-error 'type-error (mapcan #'identity (list 42)))) + (locally (declare (inline mapcan)) + (assert-error 'type-error (mapcan #'identity (list 42))))) + +(define-test mapcon-accumulate-non-nil-signals-type-error + (locally (declare (notinline mapcan)) + (assert-error 'type-error (mapcon #'car (list 42)))) + (locally (declare (inline mapcan)) + (assert-error 'type-error (mapcon #'car (list 42))))) + +(define-test mapcan-accumulate-nil-returns-nil + (locally (declare (notinline mapcan)) + (assert-equal '() (mapcan (constantly nil) '(1))) + (assert-equal '() (mapcan (constantly nil) '(1 2))) + (assert-equal '() (mapcan (constantly nil) '(1 2 3)))) + (locally (declare (inline mapcan)) + (assert-equal '() (mapcan (constantly nil) '(1))) + (assert-equal '() (mapcan (constantly nil) '(1 2))) + (assert-equal '() (mapcan (constantly nil) '(1 2 3))))) + +(define-test mapcon-accumulate-nil-returns-nil + (locally (declare (notinline mapcon)) + (assert-equal '() (mapcon (constantly nil) '(1))) + (assert-equal '() (mapcon (constantly nil) '(1 2))) + (assert-equal '() (mapcon (constantly nil) '(1 2 3)))) + (locally (declare (inline mapcon)) + (assert-equal '() (mapcon (constantly nil) '(1))) + (assert-equal '() (mapcon (constantly nil) '(1 2))) + (assert-equal '() (mapcon (constantly nil) '(1 2 3))))) + +(define-test mapcan-accumulate-one-list-returns-same-list + (locally (declare (notinline mapcan)) + (let ((list1 (list 1))) + (assert-eq list1 (mapcan (constantly list1) '(nil))))) + (locally (declare (inline mapcan)) + (let ((list1 (list 1))) + (assert-eq list1 (mapcan (constantly list1) '(nil)))))) + +(define-test mapcon-accumulate-one-list-returns-same-list + (locally (declare (notinline mapcon)) + (let ((list1 (list 1))) + (assert-eq list1 (mapcon (constantly list1) '(nil))))) + (locally (declare (inline mapcon)) + (let ((list1 (list 1))) + (assert-eq list1 (mapcon (constantly list1) '(nil)))))) + +(define-test mapcan-accumulate-two-lists-returns-same-lists + (locally (declare (notinline mapcan)) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcan #'identity (list list1 list2)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12)))) + (locally (declare (inline mapcan)) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcan #'identity (list list1 list2)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12))))) + +(define-test mapcon-accumulate-two-lists-returns-same-lists + (locally (declare (notinline mapcon)) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcon #'car (list list1 list2)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12)))) + (locally (declare (inline mapcon)) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcon #'car (list list1 list2)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12))))) + +(define-test mapcan-accumulate-two-lists-skips-nil-returns-same-lists + (locally (declare (notinline mapcan)) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcan #'identity (list nil list1 list2)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12))) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcan #'identity (list list1 nil list2)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12))) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcan #'identity (list list1 list2 nil)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12)))) + (locally (declare (inline mapcan)) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcan #'identity (list nil list1 list2)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12))) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcan #'identity (list list1 nil list2)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12))) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcan #'identity (list list1 list2 nil)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12))))) + +(define-test mapcon-accumulate-two-lists-skips-nil-returns-same-lists + (locally (declare (notinline mapcon)) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcon #'car (list nil list1 list2)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12))) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcon #'car (list list1 nil list2)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12))) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcon #'car (list list1 list2 nil)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12)))) + (locally (declare (inline mapcon)) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcon #'car (list nil list1 list2)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12))) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcon #'car (list list1 nil list2)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12))) + (let* ((list1 (list 1)) + (list2 (list 2)) + (list12 (mapcon #'car (list list1 list2 nil)))) + (assert-eq list1 list12) + (assert-eq list2 (cdr list12))))) + +(define-test mapcan-accumulate-same-list-twice-returns-circular-list + (locally (declare (notinline mapcan)) + (let ((list12 (list 1 2))) + ;; check that list12 equals #1=(1 2 . #1#) + (assert-eq list12 (mapcan (constantly list12) '(nil nil))) + (assert-eql 1 (elt list12 0)) + (assert-eql 2 (elt list12 1)) + (assert-eq (nthcdr 2 list12) list12))) + (locally (declare (inline mapcan)) + (let ((list12 (list 1 2))) + ;; check that list12 equals #1=(1 2 . #1#) + (assert-eq list12 (mapcan (constantly list12) '(nil nil))) + (assert-eql 1 (elt list12 0)) + (assert-eql 2 (elt list12 1)) + (assert-eq (nthcdr 2 list12) list12)))) + +(define-test mapcon-accumulate-same-list-twice-returns-circular-list + (locally (declare (notinline mapcon)) + (let ((list12 (list 1 2))) + ;; check that list12 equals #1=(1 2 . #1#) + (assert-eq list12 (mapcon (constantly list12) '(nil nil))) + (assert-eql 1 (elt list12 0)) + (assert-eql 2 (elt list12 1)) + (assert-eq (nthcdr 2 list12) list12))) + (locally (declare (notinline mapcon)) + (let ((list12 (list 1 2))) + ;; check that list12 equals #1=(1 2 . #1#) + (assert-eq list12 (mapcon (constantly list12) '(nil nil))) + (assert-eql 1 (elt list12 0)) + (assert-eql 2 (elt list12 1)) + (assert-eq (nthcdr 2 list12) list12))))

View it on GitLab: https://gitlab.common-lisp.net/cmucl/cmucl/-/compare/33f117246e2a9315b33bc09...