![](https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/da8638bce265a9edbab91dd837042d03.jpg?s=120&d=mm&r=g)
I was just testing out the version of ITERATE with Ilya's new fixes. Question: what do we expect to happen when `ASDF:TEST-SYSTEM` is run on iterate? I see 8 test failures, on ACL 10.1, as follows: ``` 8 out of 267 total tests failed: ITERATE.TEST::ALWAYS.FINALLY, ITERATE.TEST::NEVER.FINALLY, ITERATE.TEST::THEREIS.FINALLY, ITERATE.TEST::CODE-MOVEMENT.ELSE, ITERATE.TEST::CODE-MOVEMENT.FINALLY, ITERATE.TEST::CODE-MOVEMENT.FINALLY-PROTECTED, ITERATE.TEST::BUG/WALK.2, ITERATE.TEST::BUG/COLLECT-AT-BEGINNING. ``` Is there some way for us to tell whether this is a regression, or if these are all known issues? I figure the tests prefixed with `BUG/` are probably known failures, but what about the other 6? Would it be possible to put a list of canonical test results on the iterate project page? Thanks!
![](https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/da8638bce265a9edbab91dd837042d03.jpg?s=120&d=mm&r=g)
On 24 Jan 2018, at 15:09, Robert Goldman wrote:
I was just testing out the version of ITERATE with Ilya's new fixes. Question: what do we expect to happen when `ASDF:TEST-SYSTEM` is run on iterate? I see 8 test failures, on ACL 10.1, as follows:
``` 8 out of 267 total tests failed: ITERATE.TEST::ALWAYS.FINALLY, ITERATE.TEST::NEVER.FINALLY, ITERATE.TEST::THEREIS.FINALLY, ITERATE.TEST::CODE-MOVEMENT.ELSE, ITERATE.TEST::CODE-MOVEMENT.FINALLY, ITERATE.TEST::CODE-MOVEMENT.FINALLY-PROTECTED, ITERATE.TEST::BUG/WALK.2, ITERATE.TEST::BUG/COLLECT-AT-BEGINNING. ```
Is there some way for us to tell whether this is a regression, or if these are all known issues? I figure the tests prefixed with `BUG/` are probably known failures, but what about the other 6?
Would it be possible to put a list of canonical test results on the iterate project page?
Thanks!
If it helps, my antique version of iterate failed only with these two: ``` 2 out of 263 total tests failed: ITERATE.TEST::BUG/WALK.2, ITERATE.TEST::BUG/COLLECT-AT-BEGINNING. ``` ... but that old version does not have `ALWAYS.FINALLY`, `NEVER.FINALLY`, or `THEREIS.FINALLY`. Still, it had `CODE-MOVEMENT.FINALLY` and `CODE-MOVEMENT.FINALLY-PROTECTED`, so those two tests look like a regression to me. Best, r
participants (1)
-
Robert Goldman